Opened 12 years ago

Closed 12 years ago

Last modified 12 years ago

#292 closed task (fixed)

MeasureTool - complete recreation using GeoExt.ux.Measure

Reported by: adube Owned by:
Priority: major Milestone: 1.2.0
Component: widgets Version: trunk
Keywords: bis-1.2.0, measure, measuretool, deprecate, ux Cc:

Description

MeasureTool status

It was mentioned in #291 that the MeasureTool widget completely overrides (replaces) native OpenLayers.Control.Measure methods and properties without extending them, which is a bad thing. The way that widget was made is wrong and should be re-made.

Solution : GeoExt.ux.Measure

An other solution could be to integrate the !GeoExt.ux.Measure ux widget, which is already an official GeoExt ux and deprecate the MeasureTool.

If that new widget misses features the old one did, then the changes could be contributed to the GeoExt community.

Any thoughts ?

Change History (8)

comment:1 by adube, 12 years ago

Milestone: 1.0.0

comment:2 by adube, 12 years ago

Summary: Add GeoExt.ux.Measure, deprecate MeasureToolMeasureTool - complete recreation using GeoExt.ux.Measure

Instead of deprecating the MeasureTool and create a new geoextux_measure one, we should simply reuse the widget name, clear all widget code and start from scratch using the GeoExt.ux.Measure source.

comment:3 by adube, 12 years ago

All the tickets we should close as "wontfix" if we recreate the widget :

comment:4 by adube, 12 years ago

Milestone: 1.0.01.2.0

Since it would require to much work and time is missing, this task will be handled in the next release.

comment:5 by adube, 12 years ago

Resolution: fixed
Status: newclosed
Version: trunk

MeasureTool widget completely remade in r1229.

Technical details

  • we don't use GeoExt.ux.Measure
  • instead, we borrowed the source of the gxp.plugins.Measure from GXP library (BSD License revision)
  • widget is now one menu button that support both measure methods : "length" and "area and perimeter"
  • i18n (fr) now in javascript (.mo and .po files removed)
  • documentation and sample adjusted accordingly
  • all OpenLayers styling related options were removed

Migration

  • because the widget now supports both measure methods (lengh and area), you no longer need to define 2 widgets. Use only one
  • "tohectare" option now "hectare"
  • all OpenLayers styling related options were removed, so you no longer need them

comment:6 by adube, 12 years ago

r1230, featuring :

  • old class names used by the toolbar for the controls were removed.

Migration

  • css class name, instead of "measuretoolArea", use "gp-measuretool-icon-measure-area"
  • css class name, instead of "measuretoolLength", use "gp-measuretool-icon-measure-length"

comment:7 by adube, 12 years ago

r1232, fr typo fix.

comment:8 by adube, 12 years ago

Keywords: bis-1.2.0 added
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.