Blank PDF on Mapserver 5.0 with FastCGI

Could you please try running that same request with the mapserv CGI under valgrind and see if it reports any error?

Also, can you share a small testcase to reproduce?

One additional question: does the FastCGI binary fail to produce output with any of the other renderers?

Replying to dmorissette:

Could you please try running that same request with the mapserv CGI under valgrind and see if it reports any error?

I found an error, both with PDF and GDAL/PNG renderers, see attachments...

Also, can you share a small testcase to reproduce?

I used a simple raster layer from a DEM file:

 LAYER
    NAME "w020n90"
    DATA "/home/mapserver/data/w020n90/W020N90.DEM"
    TYPE RASTER
    STATUS ON
    DEBUG ON

    PROJECTION
      "init=epsg:4326"
    END
 END #LAYER

I think it can be reproducible with any raster layer.

A sample request: http://url/ms/raster?MODE=map&LAYER=w020n90&MAPEXT=-20%2040%2020%2090&MAPSIZE=400%20400&map.imagetype=pdf

Replying to zjames:

Jpeg: OK
Debug from FCGI

Wed Nov 21 08:47:03 2007,6624,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution

Debug from CGI

Wed Nov 21 08:47:26 2007,6841,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution
[Wed Nov 21 08:47:26 2007].524365 CGI Request 1 on process 6841
[Wed Nov 21 08:47:26 2007].528530 msDrawRasterLayerLow(w020n90): entering.
[Wed Nov 21 08:47:26 2007].533156 msDrawGDAL(): src=0,0,4800,6000, dst=40,0,320,399

Also with gif, GTiff and PNG

SVG: OK
Debug from FCGI

Wed Nov 21 09:01:54 2007,6624,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution

Debug from CGI

Wed Nov 21 09:02:34 2007,6853,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution
[Wed Nov 21 09:02:34 2007].85839 CGI Request 1 on process 6853
[Wed Nov 21 09:02:34 2007].90497 msDrawRasterLayerLow(w020n90): entering.
[Wed Nov 21 09:02:34 2007].95342 msDrawGDAL(): src=0,0,4800,6000, dst=40,0,320,399

SWF:OK
Debug from FCGI

Wed Nov 21 09:03:11 2007,6624,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution
Wed Nov 21 09:03:16 2007,6624,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution

Debug from CGI

Wed Nov 21 09:06:03 2007,6859,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution
[Wed Nov 21 09:06:03 2007].552485 CGI Request 1 on process 6859
[Wed Nov 21 09:06:03 2007].555944 msDrawRasterLayerLow(w020n90): entering.
[Wed Nov 21 09:06:03 2007].560676 msDrawGDAL(): src=0,0,4800,6000, dst=40,0,320,399
Wed Nov 21 09:06:04 2007,6865,10.102.190.102,Prove,3,-25.000000 40.000000 25.000000
 90.000000,-1.000000 -1.000000,w020n90 ,normal execution
[Wed Nov 21 09:06:04 2007].513076 CGI Request 1 on process 6865
[Wed Nov 21 09:06:04 2007].516573 msDrawRasterLayerLow(w020n90): entering.
[Wed Nov 21 09:06:04 2007].521294 msDrawGDAL(): src=0,0,4800,6000, dst=40,0,320,399

I had a look at the valgrind outputs, and I don't think that error in Exit() from main() is related to MapServer. I've seen this before with FGS builds and suspect it's related to the build or runtime environment doing something odd, but in general the binaries work fine anyway since the failure is only on Exit.

Since both PDF and PNG outputs fail then I don't think this can be called PDF-specific issue. BTW, does the PNG test also return a 0 byte output?

I see 3 possibilities:

1- FastCGI issue or side-effect: Can you try with a build without FastCGI and see if the problem goes away?

2- Build/runtime libs or environment problem: did you try the same mapfile on another machine?

3- Problem with this specific .DEM data file: in this case we'd need a testcase to reproduce.

Replying to dmorissette:

Since both PDF and PNG outputs fail then I don't think this can be called PDF-specific issue. BTW, does the PNG test also return a 0 byte output?

No,PNG is OK

I see 3 possibilities: 1- FastCGI issue or side-effect: Can you try with a build without FastCGI and see if the problem goes away?

I think it's unnecessary. I tried with the same binary without mod_fcgid and it works!! Because this, I think you are right: maybe this is a FastCGI side-effect or maybe an environment problem.

2- Build/runtime libs or environment problem: did you try the same mapfile on another machine?

I tested it also with line and point vectors from Oracle Spatial. Same as previous tests, it works as CGI and it doesn't work on FCGI only on PDF imagetype.

Mind the difference on debug output, it's different but the generated images are both OK, why ?

Scanning msSaveImagePDF() it appears that all output of the PDF to stdout is done using fwrite() and is presumably not being routed through the msIO_ layer which is required to return fastcgi stuff properly.

I can prepare a modification to mappdf.c if someone else can test it.

Franck, I am setup with factgi locally so I can do the initial tests. I can confirm right now that I get a blank output in fatscgi and a pdf doc in non fast cgi.

Assefa, I have modify fwrite() to be msIO_fwrite() in trunk (r7070). If this works fine for you it should be ported back into 5.0 branch as well. Milestone set accordingly.

tested in trunk and It works in fastcgi and in non facgi mode.

back ported in 5.0.x r7071.

ivanopicco : please confirm that it works for you so we can close the bug.

No, it doesn't work. It works in non fastcgi mode and it doesn't in fastcgi (blank file). Tested with mapserver revision r7079 and also with patch from r7070 applied on mapserver 5.0.0 stable release.

Hi all, I made a simple mapfile you can use to reply my tests:

MAP
  NAME HELLO
  STATUS ON
  EXTENT 0 0 4000 3000
  SIZE 400 300
  IMAGECOLOR 255 200 255
  WEB
    IMAGEPATH "/tmp/"
    IMAGEURL "/tmp/"
  END
  LAYER
    NAME "credits"
    STATUS DEFAULT
    TRANSFORM FALSE
    TYPE ANNOTATION
    FEATURE
      POINTS
        200 150
      END
      TEXT 'Hello World!'
    END
    CLASS
      LABEL
        TYPE BITMAP
        COLOR 0 0 0
      END
    END
  END
END

With this you get an image with an "Hello World!" in the middle. With a pdf request you get a blank pdf file with CGI (it's a white page, not void) and a empty file with FastCGI

A sample request: http://localhost/cgi-bin/mapserv?map=hello-world.map&MODE=map&map_imagetype=pdf

I hope it could be useful

I have retested with the map file provided and I get in both cases a valid empty pdf files. Not sure at this point why it does not work for you.

Don't mind me. I tried to rebuild all on another machine: it works. Thanks