geos-3.2.2 on ARM: make check fails

[jlpoole]

OS: Gentoo plug geos-3.2.2 # cat /proc/version Linux version 2.6.33.5 (root@plug) (gcc version 4.4.4 (Gentoo 4.4.4-r1 p1.1, pie-0.4.5) ) #3 PREEMPT Thu Sep 2 07:47:34 PDT 2010 plug geos-3.2.2 #

Platform: Marvel SheevaPlug? ARMv5tel-softfloat

To geos-3.2.2 I applied the ARM patch referenced in Ticket 222  http://trac.osgeo.org/geos/ticket/222. 'make' worked. 'make install' worked 'make check' failed:

Making check in xmltester make[2]: Entering directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' make check-TESTS make[3]: Entering directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' sh ./testrunner.sh testrunner ./tests/testLeaksBig.xml ./tests/split.xml ./tests/hexwkb.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/linemerge.xml ./tests/TestIsValid.xml ./tests/robustness.xml ./tests/buffer.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/singlesidedbuffer.xml ./tests/bug176.xml ./tests/bug188.xml ./tests/bug244.xml ./tests/bug275.xml ./tests/general/TestBoundary.xml ./tests/general/TestBuffer.xml ./tests/general/TestBufferMitredJoin.xml ./tests/general/TestCentroid.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull-big.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPP.xml ./tests/general/TestInteriorPoint.xml ./tests/general/TestRectanglePredicate.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePP.xml ./tests/general/TestSimple.xml ./tests/general/TestValid.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2-big.xml ./tests/general/TestWithinDistance.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20061020.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20070119.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustOverlayFixed.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustRelate.xml ./tests/fme.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal2.xml ./tests/heisenbugs.xml ./tests/badguy3.xml ./tests/hole_from_shell.xml ./tests/hole_red.xml ./tests/safe/16595.xml ./tests/safe/16596.xml Runner: testrunner created bufferOriginalPrecision failed (TopologyException?: assigned depths do not match at 1.33558e+06 631781), trying with reduced precision recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+10 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+09 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 bufferOriginalPrecision failed (TopologyException?: assigned depths do not match at 1.33559e+06 631780), trying with reduced precision recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+10 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+09 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 XMLTester: GeometryComponentFilter?.cpp:35: virtual void geos::geom::GeometryComponentFilter::filter_ro(const geos::geom::Geometry*): Assertion `0' failed. ./testrunner: line 1: 27195 Aborted ./XMLTester -v ./tests/testLeaksBig.xml ./tests/split.xml ./tests/hexwkb.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/linemerge.xml ./tests/TestIsValid.xml ./tests/robustness.xml ./tests/buffer.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/singlesidedbuffer.xml ./tests/bug176.xml ./tests/bug188.xml ./tests/bug244.xml ./tests/bug275.xml ./tests/general/TestBoundary.xml ./tests/general/TestBuffer.xml ./tests/general/TestBufferMitredJoin.xml ./tests/general/TestCentroid.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull-big.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPP.xml ./tests/general/TestInteriorPoint.xml ./tests/general/TestRectanglePredicate.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePP.xml ./tests/general/TestSimple.xml ./tests/general/TestValid.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2-big.xml ./tests/general/TestWithinDistance.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20061020.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20070119.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustOverlayFixed.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustRelate.xml ./tests/fme.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal2.xml ./tests/heisenbugs.xml ./tests/badguy3.xml ./tests/hole_from_shell.xml ./tests/hole_red.xml ./tests/safe/16595.xml ./tests/safe/16596.xml FAIL: testrunner ================== 1 of 1 test failed ================== make[3]: *** [check-TESTS] Error 1 make[3]: Leaving directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' make[2]: *** [check-am] Error 2 make[2]: Leaving directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' make[1]: *** [check-recursive] Error 1 make[1]: Leaving directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests' make: *** [check-recursive] Error 1 plug geos-3.2.2 #

Is my problem that I'm trying to perform floating point intensive calculations on a platform that does not support floating point in hardware, but uses softfloat?

[strk]

No, your problem seems to be a bogus compiler, as GeometryComponentFilter::filter_ro should not be called, but rather its implementation in derivative class should.

GeometryComponentFilter?.cpp:35: virtual void geos::geom::GeometryComponentFilter::filter_ro(const geos::geom::Geometry*): Assertion `0' failed.

[jlpoole]

Good insight. I compiled on the ARM Plug using a distributed compiler to an AMD cross compiler. I'll turn off the distcc and recompile (slooowly) on the native platform and then update my results of 'make check' here.

[jlpoole]

I compiled the project using a native compiler, compilation was fine. Same error occurred during the testing phase:

make check-TESTS make[3]: Entering directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' sh ./testrunner.sh testrunner ./tests/testLeaksBig.xml ./tests/split.xml ./tests/hexwkb.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/linemerge.xml ./tests/TestIsValid.xml ./tests/robustness.xml ./tests/buffer.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/singlesidedbuffer.xml ./tests/bug176.xml ./tests/bug188.xml ./tests/bug244.xml ./tests/bug275.xml ./tests/general/TestBoundary.xml ./tests/general/TestBuffer.xml ./tests/general/TestBufferMitredJoin.xml ./tests/general/TestCentroid.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull-big.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPP.xml ./tests/general/TestInteriorPoint.xml ./tests/general/TestRectanglePredicate.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePP.xml ./tests/general/TestSimple.xml ./tests/general/TestValid.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2-big.xml ./tests/general/TestWithinDistance.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20061020.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20070119.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustOverlayFixed.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustRelate.xml ./tests/fme.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal2.xml ./tests/heisenbugs.xml ./tests/badguy3.xml ./tests/hole_from_shell.xml ./tests/hole_red.xml ./tests/safe/16595.xml ./tests/safe/16596.xml Runner: testrunner created bufferOriginalPrecision failed (TopologyException?: assigned depths do not match at 1.33558e+06 631781), trying with reduced precision recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+10 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+09 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 bufferOriginalPrecision failed (TopologyException?: assigned depths do not match at 1.33559e+06 631780), trying with reduced precision recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+10 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+09 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 XMLTester: GeometryComponentFilter?.cpp:35: virtual void geos::geom::GeometryComponentFilter::filter_ro(const geos::geom::Geometry*): Assertion `0' failed. ./testrunner: line 1: 18291 Aborted ./XMLTester -v ./tests/testLeaksBig.xml ./tests/split.xml ./tests/hexwkb.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/linemerge.xml ./tests/TestIsValid.xml ./tests/robustness.xml ./tests/buffer.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/singlesidedbuffer.xml ./tests/bug176.xml ./tests/bug188.xml ./tests/bug244.xml ./tests/bug275.xml ./tests/general/TestBoundary.xml ./tests/general/TestBuffer.xml ./tests/general/TestBufferMitredJoin.xml ./tests/general/TestCentroid.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull-big.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPP.xml ./tests/general/TestInteriorPoint.xml ./tests/general/TestRectanglePredicate.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePP.xml ./tests/general/TestSimple.xml ./tests/general/TestValid.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2-big.xml ./tests/general/TestWithinDistance.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20061020.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20070119.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustOverlayFixed.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustRelate.xml ./tests/fme.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal2.xml ./tests/heisenbugs.xml ./tests/badguy3.xml ./tests/hole_from_shell.xml ./tests/hole_red.xml ./tests/safe/16595.xml ./tests/safe/16596.xml FAIL: testrunner ================== 1 of 1 test failed ================== make[3]: *** [check-TESTS] Error 1 make[3]: Leaving directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' make[2]: *** [check-am] Error 2 make[2]: Leaving directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests/xmltester' make[1]: *** [check-recursive] Error 1 make[1]: Leaving directory `/usr/local/src/geos-3.2.2/tests' make: *** [check-recursive] Error 1 plug geos-3.2.2 #

What do you recommend I do next? Are there certain compiler flags at play, is there something I can provide which will reveal the problem?

[jlpoole]

I had not realized "configure" might have delegated some compiles to the distributed compiler, so with the distcc turned off, I reran configure, then I did makes outputting STDOUT to files for analysis. Here are the STDERR messages generated during those sessions:

plug geos-3.2.2 # make > make-nodistcc.log tinyxml/tinyxml.cpp: In member function âvoid TiXmlAttribute::SetDoubleValue?(double)â: tinyxml/tinyxml.cpp:1269: warning: ISO C++ does not support the â%lfâ gnu_printf format plug geos-3.2.2 # make check >make-check-nodistcc.log bufferOriginalPrecision failed (TopologyException?: assigned depths do not match at 1.33558e+06 631781), trying with reduced precision recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+10 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+09 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 bufferOriginalPrecision failed (TopologyException?: assigned depths do not match at 1.33559e+06 631780), trying with reduced precision recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+10 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+10 recomputing with precision scale factor = 1e+09 Scaler: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 ReScaler?: offsetX,Y: 0,0 scaleFactor: 1e+09 XMLTester: GeometryComponentFilter?.cpp:35: virtual void geos::geom::GeometryComponentFilter::filter_ro(const geos::geom::Geometry*): Assertion `0' failed. ./testrunner: line 1: 14920 Aborted ./XMLTester -v ./tests/testLeaksBig.xml ./tests/split.xml ./tests/hexwkb.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/linemerge.xml ./tests/TestIsValid.xml ./tests/robustness.xml ./tests/buffer.xml ./tests/test.xml ./tests/singlesidedbuffer.xml ./tests/bug176.xml ./tests/bug188.xml ./tests/bug244.xml ./tests/bug275.xml ./tests/general/TestBoundary.xml ./tests/general/TestBuffer.xml ./tests/general/TestBufferMitredJoin.xml ./tests/general/TestCentroid.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull.xml ./tests/general/TestConvexHull-big.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionAA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLAPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionLL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPA.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPLPrec.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPL.xml ./tests/general/TestFunctionPP.xml ./tests/general/TestInteriorPoint.xml ./tests/general/TestRectanglePredicate.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePL.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateAC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelateLC.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePA.xml ./tests/general/TestRelatePP.xml ./tests/general/TestSimple.xml ./tests/general/TestValid.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2.xml ./tests/general/TestValid2-big.xml ./tests/general/TestWithinDistance.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20061020.xml ./tests/stmlf/stmlf-cases-20070119.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustOverlayFixed.xml ./tests/robust/TestRobustRelate.xml ./tests/fme.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal.xml ./tests/TestBufferExternal2.xml ./tests/heisenbugs.xml ./tests/badguy3.xml ./tests/hole_from_shell.xml ./tests/hole_red.xml ./tests/safe/16595.xml ./tests/safe/16596.xml make[3]: *** [check-TESTS] Error 1 make[2]: *** [check-am] Error 2 make[1]: *** [check-recursive] Error 1 make: *** [check-recursive] Error 1 plug geos-3.2.2 #

[strk]

jlpoole: still interested ? Any luck lately ? If you're still with us please post the new output from geos-3.2.3, and wrap your preformatted text in 3 brackets (as does the 5th button in the editor)

[jlpoole]

I downloaded geos-3.3.0.tar.bz2 and did the following:

./configure make make check make install

No errors. I have the logs of the above, except for "make". Please let me know if I should make them available anywhere.

I don't have to time until next week to see what install did or configuration. But, as far as this ticket is concerned, the problem I came to you with has been resolved in this newer release.

Thank you.